For those of you who are not avid followers of the
Eurovision Song Contest, "Europe's living a celebration" was the Spanish entry in 2003. It came 5th.
The following year the UK entry was "Cry Baby". It came last having received no points (or nul points as they say in Paris). The singers blamed the crushing defeat on the British government's position on Iraq. Forget that it was a f*^&%$g awful song. No, the only reason they lost so humiliatingly, was because Tony sided with his good friend Dubya. Like, get over it.
The reason for mentioning it here is that the European Union also has a problem with its voting system. Following the rejection of the proposed constitution by our europhile friends the French and the Dutch, voting in the EU is still regulated by the
Nice Treaty of 2001. This treaty was designed to help the EU operate better as it grows to 25 members and beyond.
But, the treaty has come in for a lot of criticism. It claims to give a vote dependant on the relative size of a country's population. But this system is imbalanced. The big four (France, Germany, Italy and the UK) all have 29 votes of a 320 total, but Germany has 25% more people. Germany also has more than double the population of Spain or Poland, but these two only have two votes less. For a proposal to be blocked only 90 votes are required which gives a lot of power to these countries. The proposed constitution in theory simplifies the voting system, but increases the required majority to 55% of the votes representing 65% of the population but maintains the requirement of having a majority of member countries.
The Eurovision Song Contest is much fairer, although by giving each country exactly the same power, it favours the smaller countries who can work together to win. The EU is unlikely to promote a similar system for that same reason, but the current system should be reconsidered.
Eurovision might not showcase the greatest musical talent, but like it or loathe it, for one night a year the continent is brought together in a way the Commission could only dream of.